{
  "schema": "unitiqx.review-lab.public.v1",
  "release": "2026-10-11",
  "updated_at": "2026-10-11T05:35:21.111067+00:00",
  "kind": "local-model-council-and-synthetic-persona-playtests",
  "not_real_humans": true,
  "no_model_generated_code_applied": true,
  "models": [
    {
      "model": "llama3.2:1b",
      "mb": 1321,
      "family": "llama",
      "parameters": "1.2B",
      "role_intent": "Novice copy and first-time player confusion suggestions",
      "tested_status": "calibration-needed",
      "real_observation": "Novelty review produced invalid field formats; rejected by grounding gate"
    },
    {
      "model": "granite3.3:2b",
      "mb": 1545,
      "family": "granite",
      "parameters": "2.5B",
      "role_intent": "Bounded structured criticism and independent proposal challenge",
      "tested_status": "independent-test-required",
      "real_observation": "Targeted storage bug fix proposal executed and separately accepted after regression test; first general audit rejected"
    },
    {
      "model": "deepseek-r1:1.5b",
      "mb": 1117,
      "family": "qwen2",
      "parameters": "1.8B",
      "role_intent": "Potential compact reasoning cross-check",
      "tested_status": "untested-for-this-pipeline",
      "real_observation": "Installed before release; not independently benchmarked in this council"
    },
    {
      "model": "qwen3:1.7b",
      "mb": 1359,
      "family": "qwen3",
      "parameters": "2.0B",
      "role_intent": "Original idea proposals and revisions",
      "tested_status": "draft-only",
      "real_observation": "Idea Foundry generated proposal and revised it after Granite challenge; a different earlier claim was contradicted by tests"
    },
    {
      "model": "all-minilm:latest",
      "mb": 46,
      "family": "bert",
      "parameters": "23M",
      "role_intent": "Vector embeddings and retrieval",
      "tested_status": "embedding-only",
      "real_observation": "Installed before release; is not a general chat completion model"
    },
    {
      "model": "moondream:1.8b",
      "mb": 1738,
      "family": "phi2",
      "parameters": "1B",
      "role_intent": "Screenshot description experiment",
      "tested_status": "experimental",
      "real_observation": "Generated a mobile screenshot description that was not corroborated; do not trust without pixel/human verification"
    },
    {
      "model": "gemma3:4b",
      "mb": 3339,
      "family": "gemma3",
      "parameters": "4.3B",
      "role_intent": "Potential higher-capacity multimodal/text reserve",
      "tested_status": "reserve",
      "real_observation": "Installed before release; not benchmarked for this council under current 2vCPU workload"
    },
    {
      "model": "qwen2.5:1.5b",
      "mb": 986,
      "family": "qwen2",
      "parameters": "1.5B",
      "role_intent": "Alternate-language and accessibility hypothesis review",
      "tested_status": "calibration-needed",
      "real_observation": "First accessibility response in Chinese and mischaracterized driving keyboard controls; rejected"
    },
    {
      "model": "qwen3:0.6b",
      "mb": 523,
      "family": "qwen3",
      "parameters": "751.63M",
      "role_intent": "Low-cost classification experiment",
      "tested_status": "reserve",
      "real_observation": "Installed before release; not used for final QA"
    }
  ],
  "model_count": 9,
  "hardware_profile": "VPS / two vCPU / ~8GB RAM; runs serialized and bounded",
  "personas": [
    {
      "id": "novice",
      "alias": "Morgan / First-Time Player",
      "synthetic_persona": true,
      "model": "llama3.2:1b",
      "focus": "onboarding, clarity and first player question",
      "source": "/systemverse/index.html",
      "source_hash_prefix": "fe3c5363cf87",
      "status": "rejected",
      "quality_score": 0,
      "elapsed_seconds": 26.63,
      "input_tokens": 1089,
      "generated_tokens": 157,
      "issue": null,
      "note": "Hypothesis only; source-grounded quote, NOT independently confirmed defect.",
      "triage": "unverified-model-output"
    },
    {
      "id": "auditor",
      "alias": "Avery / Reliability Auditor",
      "synthetic_persona": true,
      "model": "granite3.3:2b",
      "focus": "robustness and failure states",
      "source": "/systemverse/app.js",
      "source_hash_prefix": "01512c23f1f6",
      "status": "rejected",
      "quality_score": 0,
      "elapsed_seconds": 43.23,
      "input_tokens": 785,
      "generated_tokens": 255,
      "issue": null,
      "note": "Hypothesis only; source-grounded quote, NOT independently confirmed defect.",
      "triage": "unverified-model-output"
    },
    {
      "id": "access",
      "alias": "Sam / Accessibility Tester",
      "synthetic_persona": true,
      "model": "qwen2.5:1.5b",
      "focus": "keyboard/touch/accessibility",
      "source": "/systemverse/action.js",
      "source_hash_prefix": "f4cc3d604b83",
      "status": "rejected",
      "quality_score": 0,
      "elapsed_seconds": 13.22,
      "input_tokens": 397,
      "generated_tokens": 101,
      "issue": null,
      "note": "Hypothesis only; source-grounded quote, NOT independently confirmed defect.",
      "triage": "unverified-model-output"
    },
    {
      "id": "designer",
      "alias": "Riley / Systems Designer",
      "synthetic_persona": true,
      "model": "qwen3:1.7b",
      "focus": "original mechanics and progression",
      "source": "/systemverse/sims.js",
      "source_hash_prefix": "557a6866104b",
      "status": "rejected-after-testing",
      "quality_score": 100,
      "elapsed_seconds": 21.87,
      "input_tokens": 509,
      "generated_tokens": 195,
      "issue": {
        "problem": "The educational mechanic lacks a clear, unambiguous acceptance test and fails to provide a definitive way to measure success.",
        "impact": "The mechanic is not easily assessable, making it difficult to determine if learners have achieved the intended learning outcomes.",
        "fix": "Add a scoring system that evaluates learner progress based on completed tasks or milestones, with clear feedback mechanisms.",
        "test": "A learner completes all required tasks in the simulation and demonstrates mastery of the core concept through a quiz or performance task. The system should correctly identify the learner as proficient and provide positive feedback.",
        "better_question": "How can the system ensure that learners are clearly assessed as having achieved the intended learning outcomes, regardless of their performance in the simulation?",
        "file": "/systemverse/sims.js",
        "line": 36,
        "quote": "api.message('Flow incomplete: '+online+' of '+d.sinks.length+' destinations connected.',true)"
      },
      "note": "The proposed missing-success-test claim is contradicted by the existing flow-verification implementation and three successful utility-network browser tests. Source-anchored does not mean correct.",
      "triage": "rejected-after-reproduction",
      "quality_score_kind": "format_and_quote_quality_only"
    }
  ],
  "quality_counts": {
    "accepted": 0,
    "needs_revision": 0,
    "rejected": 4,
    "verified_repairs": 1,
    "tested_operator_improvements": 1
  },
  "playtesting": {
    "suite": "Chromium scripted simulated usage, not human recruited testers",
    "passed": 14,
    "total": 14,
    "tests": [
      {
        "persona": "Synthetic novice",
        "claim": "Empty wiring grid fails visibly",
        "passed": true,
        "observed": "Flow incomplete: 0 of 1 destinations connected."
      },
      {
        "persona": "Synthetic novice",
        "claim": "Hint explains next action",
        "passed": true,
        "observed": "Lay a continuous line of placed segments between the highlighted source and all demand nodes. Use the shortest possible route."
      },
      {
        "persona": "Synthetic novice",
        "claim": "No unearned victory",
        "passed": true,
        "observed": "win screen hidden"
      },
      {
        "persona": "Synthetic mobile player",
        "claim": "No horizontal page overflow",
        "passed": true,
        "observed": "390px viewport"
      },
      {
        "persona": "Synthetic mobile player",
        "claim": "Driving controls are touch-operable",
        "passed": true,
        "observed": "touch buttons present"
      },
      {
        "persona": "Synthetic mobile player",
        "claim": "Touch input does not crash",
        "passed": true,
        "observed": "Select actions to begin. Your choices affect the simulation."
      },
      {
        "persona": "Synthetic trading skeptic",
        "claim": "Selling unowned asset disabled",
        "passed": true,
        "observed": "No short selling"
      },
      {
        "persona": "Synthetic trading skeptic",
        "claim": "Fee debited from virtual equity",
        "passed": true,
        "observed": "$10000.00 EQUITY → $9998.00 EQUITY"
      },
      {
        "persona": "Synthetic trading skeptic",
        "claim": "Simulation disclosed as fictional",
        "passed": true,
        "observed": "No real wallet"
      },
      {
        "persona": "Synthetic keyboard player",
        "claim": "Keyboard navigation moves token",
        "passed": true,
        "observed": "◆"
      },
      {
        "persona": "Synthetic keyboard player",
        "claim": "Decoy consumes limited resource",
        "passed": true,
        "observed": "TURNS 2\nSHIELDS 3\nDECOYS 1"
      },
      {
        "persona": "Synthetic creator",
        "claim": "Untrusted project name rendered literally",
        "passed": true,
        "observed": "No injected DOM node"
      },
      {
        "persona": "Synthetic creator",
        "claim": "No page exceptions",
        "passed": true,
        "observed": "[]"
      },
      {
        "persona": "Synthetic creator",
        "claim": "Narration and export tools available",
        "passed": true,
        "observed": "Browser speech + JSON"
      }
    ]
  },
  "preexisting_game_tests": {
    "twelve_missions_completed_via_chromium": true,
    "browser_checks": 41
  },
  "release_policy": {
    "human_approval_required": true,
    "evidence_quote_verified": true,
    "claims_not_conclusively_verified": true,
    "private_sources_sent_to_public_models": false,
    "raw_prompt_outputs_public": false,
    "public_model_api_enabled": false,
    "patches_automatically_applied": 0,
    "operator_reviewed_and_tested_repairs": 1,
    "rejected_model_claims_retain_private_receipts": true
  },
  "next_steps": [
    "Verify every accepted candidate by reproducing it using code and browser tests.",
    "Human testers should independently confirm usability and accessibility before release.",
    "Only create reviewed patches with rollback after tests; do not trust LLM output alone."
  ],
  "limitations": [
    "Simulated personas do not replace real humans",
    "Small local models may hallucinate or miss real defects",
    "Quote existence does not prove an issue",
    "Scoring is a lightweight rubric, not benchmark certification",
    "No automatic deployment or private model API exposed"
  ],
  "reviewed_defects": [
    {
      "id": "SV-LOCALSTORAGE-001",
      "title": "Systemverse startup fails when Storage.getItem throws SecurityError",
      "issue_class": "verified-browser-reliability",
      "status": "fixed-and-regression-tested",
      "source_public_file": "/systemverse/app.js",
      "problem": "Storage.getItem could throw and stop all game initialization.",
      "before": {
        "with_storage": "4 game cards; playable",
        "blocked_storage": "0 game cards; unhandled SecurityError"
      },
      "after": {
        "with_storage": "4 game cards; playable; 0 exceptions",
        "blocked_storage": "4 game cards; playable; 0 exceptions"
      },
      "solution": "Wrap getItem in a safe read that returns a null default on access error; avoid failing startup.",
      "model_consulted": "granite3.3:2b",
      "acceptance": "Two-context real Chromium test: normal storage and simulated denied Storage API both load the first mission without page exception.",
      "patching": "operator-reviewed code change, not autonomously executed by model",
      "evidence_path_private": "evidence/test_storage.cjs",
      "public_evidence_summary_only": true
    }
  ],
  "rubric_note": "Source-quote validity is a format gate only; candidate claims require independent reproduction. The sole syntactically grounded candidate was rejected as an unsupported critique.",
  "vision_experiment": {
    "model": "moondream:1.8b",
    "elapsed_seconds": 31.0,
    "description": "\nThe image shows a screenshot of a browser game's game page. The game page displays a blue header with white text, and a green footer with white text. The game page also includes a navigation bar with a dropdown menu and a search bar. The game page is displayed on a light brown background.",
    "verified": false,
    "caveat": "Model visual observations are unverified; physical human inspection and browser tests remain necessary"
  },
  "reviewed_improvements": [
    {
      "id": "SV-TRAFFIC-CUES-001",
      "title": "Optional predictive traffic-lane assistance for Neon Highway",
      "issue_class": "original AI-inspired operator-reviewed usability hypothesis",
      "status": "implemented-and-functional-tests-passed",
      "model_workflow": [
        "qwen3:1.7b produced original improvement draft",
        "granite3.3:2b challenged overclaims and suggested simpler alternatives",
        "qwen3:1.7b revised the plan"
      ],
      "implementation": "Added an optional Traffic Cues on/off control; when enabled it shows next deterministic hazard lane and approximate spawn countdown. Players can disable it.",
      "measurable_acceptance": "9/9 dedicated Chromium checks (toggle, forecast lane, race victory, mobile tap, no JS errors), plus 41/41 full SYSTEMVERSE mission checks.",
      "source_file": "/systemverse/action.js",
      "real_player_satisfaction_improvement_proven": false,
      "adversary_model": "programmed deterministic traffic spawning (NOT a generative learned model)",
      "independent_human_playtest_required": true,
      "no_paid_api_or_privileged_port_added": true
    }
  ],
  "acceptance_evidence": {
    "synthetic_playtest": {
      "passed": 14,
      "total": 14
    },
    "review_lab_browser": {
      "passed": 27,
      "total": 27
    },
    "systemverse_core_gameplay": {
      "passed": 41,
      "total": 41,
      "missions_completed_using_UI": 12
    },
    "storage_policy_browser_regression": {
      "passed": 2,
      "total": 2
    },
    "traffic_cue_browser_regression": {
      "passed": 9,
      "total": 9
    }
  },
  "publication_gate": "Explicit release-specific operator triage, not model-run autopublish"
}